About · Jessica Whitcutt MCIPR · Founder

I’ve been making this argument since 2017
AI has now made it impossible to ignore

A short manifesto from Jessica Whitcutt MCIPR, founder of It’s a Shovel. Bath, UK.

In January 2018, I first wrote about Reputation with Purpose. The premise was simple: the businesses that win in the long run build genuine reputation around what they actually do, what they stand for, and what they have earned the right to say. Coincidentally, that same week, Larry Fink published his landmark “A Sense of Purpose” letter to CEOs. Two people, in completely different worlds, arriving at the same conclusion independently. The framework was formally published as a PDF in March 2018. The Business Roundtable redefined corporate purpose 17 months after that. For most of the seven years that followed, the argument was whether “purpose” mattered at all. In most boardrooms, reputation work was still treated as the soft stuff.

I never thought it was the soft stuff. By then I had spent almost a decade building FTSE-level reputation programmes for SABMiller (now AB InBev). The numbers were never soft. The methodology was never soft.

Then, in 2024 and 2025, the world quietly aligned with the 2018 thesis.

Buyers stopped reading and started asking. They opened ChatGPT, Claude, or Perplexity, typed the question, and read the answer. They checked the website. They checked LinkedIn. Only then did they ring anyone. By that point, the shortlist was mostly made.

AI engines do not reward marketing. They reward authority.

When ChatGPT recommends a firm, it is not surfacing the one that paid the highest agency fee. It is surfacing the sources it has learned to trust: substantive content, third-party validation, named experts with verifiable track records, a coherent story across the web. That is not an SEO problem. It is a reputation problem. It is the problem I have been solving for 30 years, with a new technical layer underneath.

Genuine authority earns citation. Citation earns discovery. Discovery drives growth.

The framework did not need rewriting. The market needed catching up. The values argument and the commercial argument are now the same argument. The work that earns trust from buyers is the work that earns citation from machines, because the machines are trained on what humans have already learned to trust.

This is why I built It’s a Shovel for founder-led businesses, and why I will not work on anything else.

Founder-led firms have what AI search rewards and corporates spend millions trying to manufacture: a real person at the centre, with real expertise, a clear point of view, and a verifiable track record. Most of them are sitting on the single most valuable asset in the new B2B buying environment, and they have never properly built it. They hide behind a corporate “we”. They post advice instead of opinion. They buy SEO when what they need is to be cited as authorities. The mismatch is painful, and it is entirely solvable.

The founder-led firms that fix this in the next two to three years will own categories. The ones that do not will continue to depend on referrals, which is fine until it isn’t.

I want to spend the rest of my career working with the founder-led firms I have always admired most: small advisory practices, specialist consultancies, boutique professional services, the hospitality and tourism businesses with a real story to tell. The strategic communications work I built for FTSE-level brands should be available to them, at a price they can afford. That is the gap in the market, and that is what It’s a Shovel exists to close.

If you are running a founder-led firm with something genuinely useful to say, let’s talk about how to make sure the right people, and the right machines, can find you.

About Jessica

Jessica Whitcutt MCIPR is the founder of It’s a Shovel. She has 30 years of strategic communications experience on both the agency and client side, and is the creator of the Reputation with Purpose framework, first published in March 2018 and refined ever since.

Earlier in her career she led reputation for SABMiller, a FTSE Top 20 business at the time, where she designed and delivered award-winning behaviour-change campaigns, helped the business avoid regulatory risks and set up from scratch a global benchmark in corporate social media. Subsequent consulting work has spanned Unilever, BMW Group Australia, and, most recently, a UK advisory engagement that delivered a marketing-influenced pipeline of more than £550,000 in seven months.

She holds a BA Law from the University of the Witwatersrand and is a Member of the Chartered Institute of Public Relations (MCIPR), the UK’s senior professional credential for public relations practitioners. Continuing professional development includes executive programmes at the University of Cambridge Judge Business School and the Gordon Institute of Business Science in South Africa.

Born and raised in Johannesburg, Jessica has worked with clients across four continents and now lives in Bath, UK, where her free time is mostly spent hiking the surrounding countryside.

Jessica Whitcutt MCIPR, founder of It's a Shovel

What clients say

“By far the best PR and marketing executive I have worked with in my 27 year private equity career.”

Former Head of Actis Private Equity

“I have learnt a lot from working with Jessica about what executive profiling can do. She has had a huge impact on my social media profile.”

Chief Product Supply Chain Officer, Unilever

“We were thrilled to find a consultant who could add such great value from both a strategic and practical perspective.”

GM, Corporate Communications, BMW Group Australia

Featured engagement

Featured engagement: Keystone IQ

A detailed case study from the Keystone IQ engagement is in preparation and will be published here in mid-2026.

Follow the work

The strategic communications discipline is shifting month by month, particularly in how AI engines decide who to cite. The simplest way to stay current is to follow the work as it happens.

Follow Jessica on LinkedIn

Shorter notes on visibility, reputation, and what the AI search era is doing to B2B buying.

Follow on LinkedIn →

Subscribe to the It’s a Shovel newsletter

Roughly monthly notes on visibility, reputation, and B2B trust. Longer pieces, no listicles, no sales sequences.

Subscribe to the newsletter →

Or start with the free audit

Most It’s a Shovel engagements start with the free AI Visibility Heatmap. It is short, the heatmap is delivered within two working days, and the verdict tells you the right next step.